I've had this issue with BDSM romance for a while now and I
haven't been able to nail it down to something specific. One of my
best-read reviews ever was for a BDSM romance that I feel like I
really tore into and I've had a really hard time understanding why it
bothered me so much. Not just bothered in the sense that I didn't
believe in the romance even though I really liked the writing, but
also bothered me that so many other people didn't see things that way
so maybe I'm just missing something. As I follow more people on
twitter, somehow I've ended up interacting with a lot of authors that
write BDSM-style erotica. Some for a long time and some as part of
this new trend. I honestly read very few of the books just because
there's something about them that really does bother me.
Then yesterday I was reading The Hostage Bargain by Annika Martin.
It's an absorbing, fun, fantasy book with three guys and a girl as a
gang of bank robbers. I'm not quite all the way through it yet so I
don't know how it ends. So far I've been enjoying it but when they
start throwing in the BDSM, I feel a little uncomfortable. Thinking
about it all night finally flicked the light switch for me I think.
Here's the thing, there's a couple issues that really make me feel
uncomfortable. First, there's never anyone (in the limited number of
books I've read) that says the safe word. They never talk about hard
limits. They never cross the line and then have to actually
communicate to keep a relationship going. This puts me in the mindset
of those earlier romance novels where the sex scenes are angry and
rapey. The heroine doesn't actually give her consent to anything but
“she would have put up a fight if she didn't actually want it”
and then later they're all totally in love. The heroine comes to
expect that she can't actually talk to the hero or express her own
desires. As long as she's willing to receive whatever the hero gives,
it's all good. And she just loves him so much that it doesn't really
matter if he waits for a “yes” or not.
In these BDSM books, they never run into an issue were one of the
characters truly doesn't like what's happening. Even when the book
sort-of implies they don't like it, they don't say the safe word
because they don't want to miss out on what might happen next. What
kind of relationship do you make with someone where if you were to
say “stop, I don't like this”, they just walk away and say we
can't actually have a relationship. That seems so abusive and
manipulative and full of patriarchal influence. “As long as you let
me do whatever I want, I'll be with you. But if you say no to
anything, we're done. Even though we've just met, you can totally
trust me to cause you pain but make sure it's 'worth it in the end'
because I'm just a stand up sort of guy.” I've had enough
experience with abusive and manipulative people that I just cringe as
I read some of this.
I want to scream at the heroine “just say the safe word! Make a
relationship where everyone knows that you can say No if you want
to!” I'm not saying that everyone has to like or not like the same
things. But I do want to see people stand up for themselves. I'd like
to see romance tackle the hard stuff like having a conversation
beforehand about what hard limits they have. Or stopping because
someone said no, then talking it out and keep going with the new
boundaries. I'd like to see conversations of “I don't want to do
this now, but maybe I'd be willing to try some other day”. I'd like
to see the dominant character hear a “no”/safe word and
graciously accept it without implying the relationship is over.
Trust goes both ways in a relationship and it feels like a lot of
the BDSM-style romance asks the submissive character to put all trust
in the dominant without actually receiving any trust in return. “You
can be with me, as long as you don't question me. The minute you do,
we're done.” I have such a hard time believing in a love story where
they haven't actually talked it out or where either character gets
away with never having to accept a no and/or compromise.
Now I'm not saying that the vague consent, patriarchal, or rapey
feel is the intention that any of these authors are going for.
There's some compelling element of imagination/fantasy to these
stories that I can understand, but I have trouble believing the
romance. But these are my own issues and I own them for what they
are. We've all had our own experiences and obviously mine come through in the way I look at things when I read. But it still makes
me feel uncomfortable and very careful about which books I pick up.
So, what do you think? Do you think there's a correlation between
the earlier romances with rapey elements and today's prevalence of
BDSM romance? Do you have any recommendations for books that actually
address some of these issues and/or communicate without simply saying
“trust me”? Is there some other way I could look at these issues?
Do you think people are reading these for the nonconsensual/rape
fantasy theme anyway vs. believing the love story itself?